UK Retail Equal Pay Cases: Key Lessons for EU Employers on Pay Transparency

SkillsTrust

• 4 minute read

With the EU Pay Transparency Directive due to become law by 7th June 2026, many employers are trying to work out what to expect. The UK has seen a slew of recent equal pay claims across the retail sector, presenting a great learning opportunity for EU employers. In this article, we identify the lessons we can learn from these cases ahead of new pay transparency laws. 

But First, a Little Context

In the UK, to win an equal pay claim, claimants must be successful in three areas, each of which comprises one stage in the legal proceedings: 

  1. Comparability - for an equal pay claim to be brought, a claimant must be able to compare themselves to a valid comparator - a current or previous worker - of another gender. This must be a real person employed by the same, or an associated, employer. 

  2. Equal value - the claimant must establish that they and the comparator are employed in like work, in jobs of equal value, or in jobs rated as equivalent as per the Equality Act 2010. 

  3. Material factor defence - if the court rules in the claimant’s favour for points one and two, it’s up to the employer to show the reason for the inequality is due to a material factor - this cannot be the difference in the comparators’ sex. If the employer cannot demonstrate this, the claimant wins.

All three of these elements will also apply under articles 18 and 19 of the new EU Pay Transparency Directive.

One retail sector equal pay case that’s recently completed all three stages is the Thandi and others v Next Retail Ltd case. So let’s dive into the details.

Next Shop Workers Win Equal Pay Battle

The situation

3,500 predominantly female Next store workers claimed they were being paid lower wages than the mainly male warehouse workforce between 2012 and 2023. Next argued that market forces explained the pay difference and that the sex of staff did not come into how they set the pay. 

The ruling

The Employment Tribunal ruled that Next:

This left cost saving as Next’s only defence, which was not considered to be sufficient justification for the pay inequities. 

The outcome

Each claimant has lost more than £6,000 on average and is entitled to up to six years’ back pay. With a total cost of as much as £30m, unsurprisingly, Next plans to appeal the ruling.

Implications of the Next Ruling for Supermarkets 

The Next case is important because it sets the scene for a number of similar equal pay claims against supermarket chains Asda, Tesco, Morrison’s, Sainsbury’s and the Co-Op. All the claims centre around people in shop floor roles (who are mostly female) being paid less than people (who are mostly male) in warehouse or distribution centre roles . 

In all the cases, claimants have passed the comparability hurdle. Asda claimants must prove the roles are of equal value while the equal value rulings are due for Morrisons and the Co-Op at the end of 2024. 

The most interesting legal findings are:

  1. Tesco

The European Court of Justice ruled claimants can compare their roles to higher-paid distribution workers, even though the comparators were in different establishments. This is because the employer was deemed to be a single source with the power to correct the pay difference.  

  1. Sainsbury’s

Sainsbury’s conceded stage one, comparability. But only after trying to have the case thrown out on the basis of a technicality (relating to some claimants’ names and addresses being omitted from early conciliation forms). However, the judge ruled in the claimants’ favour, saying: “It has been repeatedly stated that employment tribunals should do their best not to place artificial barriers in the way of genuine claims.”

Implications for EU Employers in Relation to the EU Pay Transparency Directive

So what can we learn from these UK retail cases?

  1. Trying to fight a legal case on the basis of a technicality might not work. UK judges understand the spirit of current equal pay laws and European judges could well apply the same principles to future pay equity cases under the Directive. This makes robust pay practises a vital part of your HR strategy.

  2. Equal pay cases are extremely time consuming and resource intensive. Making an equal pay claim a major business risk. In the case of the UK supermarkets’ equal pay claims, the total cost could be as much as £8bn in back pay alone. Not to mention the cost of legal fees and the time and resources expended internally to boot. Doing the work now to reduce your company’s pay transparency risk is likely to be a sound return on investment.

  3. Employees can compare their pay to others even if they don’t work for the same employer.  The EU Pay Transparency Directive will apply the single source test which means employees will be able to compare their pay to others’ even if they don't work for the same employer - as long as the pay conditions are set centrally for more than one employer.

  4. Using market rates as your sole equal pay defence won’t cut it. The new pay transparency legislation requires any pay gap between roles of equal value to be 5% or less. Trying to justify larger gaps than this, on the basis of market rates, won’t be successful. Instead, you need to be able to prove objective differences between roles, like skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions. A job levelling framework is a good way to do this.

  5. When employers shoulder the burden of proof, it can be more difficult to win cases.

Under the Pay Transparency Directive, you must be able to show the reason for a pay inequality is due to a material factor that’s not the difference in sex. Again, this means pay differentials must be based on objective criteria. Employer burden of proof also makes it easier, and therefore more likely, that more employees will make claims. In the UK retail cases, tens of thousands of employees have claimed, resulting in the substantial costs mentioned earlier.

Adopting a Pay Equity Strategy

It’s clear - as an EU employer, ensuring watertight pay practices is absolutely vital. Something you can achieve by taking a strategic and thorough approach to pay.  Our team of experts recommends tackling four key areas of activity to prepare for the upcoming pay transparency legislation:

  1. Assess and adapt your pay practices.

  2. Prepare to be far more open about sharing pay information internally and when you hire.

  3. Get ready for new external reporting requirements.

  4. Act now to reduce risks if a claim is filed.

We go into much more detail about each of these activities in our pay transparency preparedness checklist. It’s been designed to help you spot the gaps in your pay practices. So you can easily identify what you need to do to prepare for the upcoming pay transparency legislation and reduce your risk of a costly equal pay claim in future. 

Get my free checklist

Read more articles

Michelle Dervan

2 Nov 2026

All About Averages | Pay Analytics 101

The Importance of the Average When talking about pay data, the term average appears time and time again, but what does it actually mean? Put simply, an average salary gives us one figure to help describe pay across a group of employees. It takes all the salary values from that group and calculates a figure that would represent a ‘typical’ employee in that group. This is useful because it allows us to compare pay between different employee groups without having to look at every individual salary. The average can become an even more powerful metric when we begin to understand and analyse the different ways it’s calculated. It might seem counterintuitive that a figure like the average can be calculated in different ways and possibly provide different answers. After all, how can the same set of salaries produce different averages? The key is that each method looks at the data differently, helping us bring a different part of the picture into focus. There are two types of average that are particularly important when it comes to understanding pay: the mean and the median. So, how do they work, and what can each tell us about pay? Let's introduce them using a simple example company, PeopleTech Ltd. The Mean: What would everyone earn if pay were shared equally? The mean is what many people think of when they hear the word average. It shows us what each employee would earn if the company's total pay were shared equally among everyone. In everyday conversation, the terms mean and average are often used interchangeably. However, this isn't technically accurate, as the mean is just one of the ways to calculate an average, as we'll explore later on. To calculate the mean, we simply add together all the salaries and divide the total by the number of employees. Let's look at the example company, PeopleTech Ltd. Imagine the five employees earn the following annual salaries: €30,000 + €40,000 + €40,000 + €50,000 + €100,000 = €260,000 PeopleTech Ltd. has a total annual salary bill of €260,000 across its five employees. To calculate the mean, we divide this total by five: €260,000 ÷ 5 = €52,000 So, the mean salary at PeopleTech Ltd. is €52,000. In other words, if the company's total salary bill were shared equally between all five employees, each person would receive €52,000. The mean is useful because it gives us an overall picture of pay across the company. However, as we'll see, it doesn't always reflect what most employees actually earn, particularly when there are significant differences between the highest and lowest salaries. The Median: What is the salary in the middle? But what happens when one or two employees earn significantly more than everyone else? This is where the median can give us a different perspective. While the mean looks at the total of all salaries, the median looks directly at the middle of the data. Imagine arranging all our employees in a straight line, from the lowest-paid to the highest-paid. The salary of the person standing in the middle would represent our median salary. Let's look at PeopleTech Ltd. again. Using the same salaries as before, we arrange them from lowest to highest: €30,000 | €40,000 | €40,000 | €50,000 | €100,000 The middle salary is €40,000, making this the median salary for PeopleTech Ltd. What makes the median particularly useful is that it is not affected by unusually high or low salaries, often referred to as outliers. In our example, let's assume the €100,000 salary belongs to the CEO, which is double the next highest salary. This unusually high salary pulls the mean upwards, making the average salary appear higher than what most employees actually earn. The median, however, is not affected by this unusually high salary. At €40,000, it gives us a different perspective on what a typical employee earns in PeopleTech Ltd. This is particularly useful for HR professionals because it helps us understand what employees typically earn, without the results being skewed by a small number of particularly high or low salaries. Neither figure is wrong. They simply tell us different things about how pay is distributed across the company. Looking at both together gives us a more complete picture than relying on either one alone. One thing to note: when there is an even number of employees, there won't be one person sitting exactly in the middle. In this case, we take the two middle salaries and calculate their average to find the median. How does this all relate to the EU Pay Transparency Directive? The EU Pay Transparency Directive requires employers to report on both the mean and median gender pay gap. These gaps are calculated by finding the average pay for male employees and the average pay for female employees, and then measuring the difference between them. The difference is expressed as a percentage of men's average pay. For example, a gender pay gap of +10% means that women's average pay is 10% lower than men's average pay. But why does the Directive want to look at both figures? The size of a company's mean gender pay gap and median gender pay gap can tell us different things about how pay is distributed across the organisation. If a company's mean gender pay gap is larger than its median gender pay gap, this could suggest that higher-paid employees are having a greater influence on the overall gap. Think back to our PeopleTech Ltd. example, where the CEO's €100,000 salary pulled the mean upwards. A similar effect could occur in an organisation where the pay gap between most male and female employees is relatively small, but a highly paid position, such as the CEO role, is occupied by a man. Even though the difference in pay across the wider workforce may be relatively modest, this one high salary could pull the mean upwards and result in a much larger overall gender pay gap. On the other hand, if a company's median gender pay gap is larger than its mean gender pay gap, this could suggest that the difference in pay is more evident across the wider workforce, rather than being driven primarily by a small number of highly or lower paid positions. In other words, the gap may be more noticeable among employees around the middle of the pay distribution, rather than being concentrated at the top. This could highlight wider differences in how men and women are paid across the organisation, and may warrant further investigation. It is important to remember that neither the mean nor the median tells us exactly why a gender pay gap exists. They are indicators that help us identify patterns and differences in pay, rather than explanations in themselves. By looking at both measures together, HR professionals can begin to build a clearer picture of pay within their organisation, identify areas that may need further investigation and take a more informed approach to understanding and addressing any gaps.

Read article

Michelle Dervan

2 Nov 2026

All About Averages | Pay Analytics 101

The Importance of the Average When talking about pay data, the term average appears time and time again, but what does it actually mean? Put simply, an average salary gives us one figure to help describe pay across a group of employees. It takes all the salary values from that group and calculates a figure that would represent a ‘typical’ employee in that group. This is useful because it allows us to compare pay between different employee groups without having to look at every individual salary. The average can become an even more powerful metric when we begin to understand and analyse the different ways it’s calculated. It might seem counterintuitive that a figure like the average can be calculated in different ways and possibly provide different answers. After all, how can the same set of salaries produce different averages? The key is that each method looks at the data differently, helping us bring a different part of the picture into focus. There are two types of average that are particularly important when it comes to understanding pay: the mean and the median. So, how do they work, and what can each tell us about pay? Let's introduce them using a simple example company, PeopleTech Ltd. The Mean: What would everyone earn if pay were shared equally? The mean is what many people think of when they hear the word average. It shows us what each employee would earn if the company's total pay were shared equally among everyone. In everyday conversation, the terms mean and average are often used interchangeably. However, this isn't technically accurate, as the mean is just one of the ways to calculate an average, as we'll explore later on. To calculate the mean, we simply add together all the salaries and divide the total by the number of employees. Let's look at the example company, PeopleTech Ltd. Imagine the five employees earn the following annual salaries: €30,000 + €40,000 + €40,000 + €50,000 + €100,000 = €260,000 PeopleTech Ltd. has a total annual salary bill of €260,000 across its five employees. To calculate the mean, we divide this total by five: €260,000 ÷ 5 = €52,000 So, the mean salary at PeopleTech Ltd. is €52,000. In other words, if the company's total salary bill were shared equally between all five employees, each person would receive €52,000. The mean is useful because it gives us an overall picture of pay across the company. However, as we'll see, it doesn't always reflect what most employees actually earn, particularly when there are significant differences between the highest and lowest salaries. The Median: What is the salary in the middle? But what happens when one or two employees earn significantly more than everyone else? This is where the median can give us a different perspective. While the mean looks at the total of all salaries, the median looks directly at the middle of the data. Imagine arranging all our employees in a straight line, from the lowest-paid to the highest-paid. The salary of the person standing in the middle would represent our median salary. Let's look at PeopleTech Ltd. again. Using the same salaries as before, we arrange them from lowest to highest: €30,000 | €40,000 | €40,000 | €50,000 | €100,000 The middle salary is €40,000, making this the median salary for PeopleTech Ltd. What makes the median particularly useful is that it is not affected by unusually high or low salaries, often referred to as outliers. In our example, let's assume the €100,000 salary belongs to the CEO, which is double the next highest salary. This unusually high salary pulls the mean upwards, making the average salary appear higher than what most employees actually earn. The median, however, is not affected by this unusually high salary. At €40,000, it gives us a different perspective on what a typical employee earns in PeopleTech Ltd. This is particularly useful for HR professionals because it helps us understand what employees typically earn, without the results being skewed by a small number of particularly high or low salaries. Neither figure is wrong. They simply tell us different things about how pay is distributed across the company. Looking at both together gives us a more complete picture than relying on either one alone. One thing to note: when there is an even number of employees, there won't be one person sitting exactly in the middle. In this case, we take the two middle salaries and calculate their average to find the median. How does this all relate to the EU Pay Transparency Directive? The EU Pay Transparency Directive requires employers to report on both the mean and median gender pay gap. These gaps are calculated by finding the average pay for male employees and the average pay for female employees, and then measuring the difference between them. The difference is expressed as a percentage of men's average pay. For example, a gender pay gap of +10% means that women's average pay is 10% lower than men's average pay. But why does the Directive want to look at both figures? The size of a company's mean gender pay gap and median gender pay gap can tell us different things about how pay is distributed across the organisation. If a company's mean gender pay gap is larger than its median gender pay gap, this could suggest that higher-paid employees are having a greater influence on the overall gap. Think back to our PeopleTech Ltd. example, where the CEO's €100,000 salary pulled the mean upwards. A similar effect could occur in an organisation where the pay gap between most male and female employees is relatively small, but a highly paid position, such as the CEO role, is occupied by a man. Even though the difference in pay across the wider workforce may be relatively modest, this one high salary could pull the mean upwards and result in a much larger overall gender pay gap. On the other hand, if a company's median gender pay gap is larger than its mean gender pay gap, this could suggest that the difference in pay is more evident across the wider workforce, rather than being driven primarily by a small number of highly or lower paid positions. In other words, the gap may be more noticeable among employees around the middle of the pay distribution, rather than being concentrated at the top. This could highlight wider differences in how men and women are paid across the organisation, and may warrant further investigation. It is important to remember that neither the mean nor the median tells us exactly why a gender pay gap exists. They are indicators that help us identify patterns and differences in pay, rather than explanations in themselves. By looking at both measures together, HR professionals can begin to build a clearer picture of pay within their organisation, identify areas that may need further investigation and take a more informed approach to understanding and addressing any gaps.

Read article

The information on this page is not intended to serve and does not serve as legal advice. All of the content, information, and material on this website are only for general informational use.

Copyright © 2026 SkillsTrust. All Rights Reserved.

The information on this page is not intended to serve and does not serve as legal advice. All of the content, information, and material on this website are only for general informational use.

Copyright © 2026 SkillsTrust. All Rights Reserved.

The information on this page is not intended to serve and does not serve as legal advice. All of the content, information, and material on this website are only for general informational use.

Copyright © 2026 SkillsTrust. All Rights Reserved.

The information on this page is not intended to serve and does not serve as legal advice. All of the content, information, and material on this website are only for general informational use.

Copyright © 2026 SkillsTrust. All Rights Reserved.